I didn’t catch the news until the following morning. I had heard the early returns that evening, but in typical fashion was too busy to follow the situation closely. When I caught the final tally on CNN the next morning, I was blown away.
The Dixie Chicks had swept the Grammy Awards.
* * * * *
To fully understand this phenomenon, you have to go back to 2003 when Dixie Chicks lead singer Natalie Maines, addressing an audience during one of their shows in London, England, told the crowd that the band was embarassed that President Bush was from Texas. The story exploded in the American press, as the fervor of flag-waving in the post-9/11 era was still in full swing. There was very little opposition to the then-fresh invasion of Iraq outside of Peacenik circles and tree-hugger conventions, and the President’s approval rating was still well above 50%. It was immediately apparent that the diminutive songstress had just opened a can of worms.
Despite reluctant support from other show-biz luminaries, many of whom doing drive-by “atta-girls” on red carpet photo-ops and then quickly disappearing before any questions could be asked, the country music community was boiling over. Many artists made a bee-line for the nearest TV camera to denounce the Chicks and re-state their support for the war and the President. Others stayed quiet, wisely staying out of a fray that was about to descend into all-out war.
Within days, country music stations were on fire will callers demanding a boycott of Dixie Chicks music from the airwaves. Caught between their support of First Amendment rights and the money they love so much, nearly the entire country radio community bowed to public pressure and shoved the Chicks’ CD’s in the dumpster overnight. The Dixie Chicks had lost the means to promote themselves.
And call them what you will, the country music community has long memories. An attempted “peace-making” press conference a few weeks later did nothing to ease tensions, and for the next two and a half years the Dixie Chicks went into hiding. We can only guess the reality of what went on in their personal and professional lives, though it is widely known that the members of the band each and collectively received numerous death threats. That one fifteen-word sentence uttered an ocean away seemed to have brought an end to one of country music’s most promising careers.
* * * * *
With almost no warning, the Dixie Chicks’ new video appeared on VH-1 in the summer of 2006. The song was “Not Ready To Make Nice,” and the video was a not-so-subtle metaphor for bloodying one’s hands for the sake of oil. The song was anthemic, bold, and a definitive statement of complete and utter dismissal of any criticism they had received. Additionally it very clearly spelled out the displays of ignorance from their former fans who had made their lives so miserable for the last three years. It was proud, it was concise, it was catchy, and it was visually remarkable.
And it shot to #1 on the VH-1 charts in a heartbeat.
The new album broke and hit the Billboard charts upon its arrival, hitting the #1 spot on that music industry bellweather before the release was a month old. Despite nearly zero country radio airplay, the Dixie Chicks’ “Taking The Long Way” was the most demonstrative hit of their careers. The album was certified Gold faster than any of their previous recordings.
I have listened to the Dixie Chicks since I heard their first single, “Wide Open Spaces,” with its flowing, fragrant harmonies and simple message of freedom. On the whole, I detest country music and all that it stands for. But the Chicks’ music touched me, and I continued to listen through “Fly” and “Home” as their sound matured and their messages broadened and deepened away from the beer/jail/pickups themes of most artists in their genre.
The new album minces no words about its political position, but also contains some genuinely frank emotions about independence, peace of mind, and dealing with the death of an elderly relative. It also side-swipes the Christian Right with a song used as part of a movie soundtrack, a documentary about Maines’ hometown of Lubbock, Texas, and the fact that it ranked #1 on the watchlist of cities for sexually transmitted diseases among teens. Long and short, your hypocritical abstinence campaign isn’t working, and it’s time to stop hiding behind God and get down to the business of saving your childrens’ lives. Clearly, the Chicks have found a new freedom in their exile, and we’ve not heard the last of them — not by a long shot.
* * * * *
Fast-forward to late 2006, when the Grammy Awards nominations were released. The Dixie Chicks’ newest album and the premiere single garnered a total of five nominations, only two of which in the country categories. The surprising news was that they were nominated in the “Big Three” of Song of the Year, Record of the Year, and Album of the Year categories. The Grammies make no secret about the fact that country music is only one step up from rap on the ladder of musical accomplishment, and for a country song/album/artist to win one of the Big Three is a rarity to say the least. The fact that the Chicks had been nominated in all three should have been seen as a sign of things to come. But at the time it was viewed as more of a, “Aw, isn’t that nice” nod from the organization. Nobody expected what would happen next.
The Chicks won one of their two nominations in the country categories during a ceremony that was not broadcast, and they failed to show up to receive the award. Such things aren’t necessarily unusual, however it was viewed as a concession on the part of the Chicks that they didn’t expect to win anything, and didn’t want to be seen in public getting snubbed by the only musical community that would have them.
But on Grammy night, the landscape changed. The Chicks were all there, dressed to the nines and proud to mingle amongst the rest of the nominees, and nabbed the other country-category award they had been nominated for. But the best was yet to come. Surprising all but the most reckless Vegas oddsmakers, the Chicks walked away with every one of the Big Three awards in succession, and cemented their place in history as one of the most shocking Grammy upsets of all time.
Three successively more raucous standing ovations greeted the three young ladies as they ascended the stage for each award, followed by a standing ovation from the press in the post-mortem interview room after the event’s conclusion. The Chicks took the opportunity to land a few body blows to the country music industry and the fans that had abandoned them in the past three years. But it was apparent by the looks on all of their faces that their victories, while satisfying, were bittersweet.
* * * * *
All you have to do is say the words “Jethro Tull” and you’ll encapsulate the bizarre nature of the Grammy decision-making process. The winners are most times chosen on their merits, however when extenuating circumstances arise, you get winners that are difficult to have foreseen. Luther Vandross conveniently winning while recuperating from a stroke; Carlos Santana winning multiple awards over (arguably) much more deserving artists simply because he had never won before; and Jethro Tull snapping a sure-thing victory from the jaws of Metallica, simply because the organization members were thumbing their nose at the introduction of the “Best Metal Album” category.
It would be foolish not to consider that the Dixie Chicks sweep fell into that category. A young and talented band comprised of young women, faced with ostricism by a vocal but ignorant public minority of toothless knuckle-draggers waving the flag so hard they spill their beer, finding refuge with other talented musicians who support them and their political views. It has all the ear-marks of a giant “F*CK YOU!!!” from the mainstream music industry to the cowards who bent to the pressure from the backwards red-necks who they rely on for their livelihoods. CMT, the originator and host for the fan-voted Country Music Awards, was quick to post an article on their web site decrying the Chicks’ victories, railing about politics over substance and more deserving artists being passed over. And I don’t think the Chicks can count on any CMA nominations this year.
But when all the dust settles, the reality of the matter is two-fold. Number one, the country music community needs to take a good, long look at itself. By continuing to bend to the collective will of the Hank Junior disciples and their ilk, they alienate millions of Americans who don’t think that way, and in fact take strong objection to the position held by these morons. Squelching free speech could not be more un-American, even if that person is criticizing your country, your government, and your leader. Freedom means the freedom to object to anything, even the freedom to object to freedom if that’s what your conscience tells you to do. That’s something these addle-minded NASCAR freaks will never comprehend, and subsequently the country music industry does itself a disservice by catering to them. Ultimately it will lead to their undoing as the country artists themselves help lead the way out of the philosophical backwater and towards mainstream Americans’ values.
But more importantly, “Taking the Long Way” is a good record, whether you’re a country music fan or not. It has just been certified double-platinum, indicating two million copies sold. With the Grammy wins under their belt I expect that number to double again, aided in no small part by the country music fans who secretly order the record from Amazon without telling their friends. In the end I expect the music to win out over the ancient history of fifteen words spoken five thousand miles from Nashville.